Laine Nooney
  • home
  • Research
  • CV
  • Projects
    • Sierra On-Line Memories
    • Mistakes Were Made
    • Softalk Open Discussion Project
    • Academic Coach Taylor
    • JVC Meme Issue
    • T42 Documentary
    • Different Games Conference
    • Freelance Graphic Design
  • Teaching
  • Blog
  • About
  • Prospective Ph.D.

Chasing the Perfect (Unteaching Perfection)

5/3/2012

 
Picture
Today I had the distinct pleasure of teaching Natalia Ilyin's Chasing the Perfect in the college-level Graphic Design History class I've been teaching as an adjunct. Teaching graphic design history has been a curious and illuminating throwback to my prior, "almost-famous" life as a graphic design critic (a long tale for another blog day).

As a scholar with a BFA in graphic design, an MA in English,  a pending Ph.D. in Cultural Studies and a grad certificate in Women's Studies, I'm a pretty sloppy disciplinarian. Thus, I didn't bat an eyelash at putting a memoir as the capstone reading for my graphic design history syllabus. And thank god I didn't, because Chasing the Perfect was the perfect culmination to a long, trotting list of dead white Western men and the ever-so "important" designs they made. 

Forgive my snideness--it's not that they weren't important, but moreso, as Ilyin might phrase it, "at what cost have they been made important?" Throughout the book, Ilyin maps the controlling, masculine tactics of modern design against her own ironically observed and amusingly described life events. Ilyin raises a simple question: Do you design out of fear, or do you design out of love? The moderns, to her, especially Bauhaus founder Walter Gropius, designed out of fear, designed to build a utopia that would protect them from the horror and brutality they witnessed in WWI. What that wrought was an unsustainable belief that design could control the mess of life, and Ilyin tracks this tendency with witty aplomb through homes of the future, graphic design grad school, the empty offices of modernist furniture designers,  and through her own psychic space--Ilyin's mental breakdown is given central space but isn't overloaded. It is written with the humor and clarity that only comes with mature distance and sincere self-observation. There's no victim here, just raw life.

One moment in the book, however, particularly held my interest. Near the end of the book, Ilyin discusses the fallacy of linear history--the impression we are given that graphic design began in the caves of France and has only marched forward on an unalterable course. Describing the art history staple of the slide lecture, she writes: "These slides link together the unlinked. They make the design past appear seamless, premeditated, a logical progression out of the caves and into the sunlight. It is as though [...] a celestial plan of progression is borne out in those slides, and that it was only a matter of time, say, until Futurism developed from all that had gone before. Which is not true. Which is picking up only one thread of a wide weave" (115).

My media studies brain perks up here--it's the practice of the slide lecture, the use of the carousel projector or power point presentation that presents a "seamless, premeditated, a logical progression" of all those images. In a wonderously clever turn, Ilyin's indites the foundation of art history teaching for misrepresenting history through its own mechanical/digital mode of presentation. As I asked my students "When I show you one slide, and then click to another slide, did you ever wonder what happened in that gap?"

I know I'm going to re-arrange the hell out of my syllabus for this class when I teach it again, but Chasing the Perfect isn't going anywhere. It's the perfect companion to Meggs, and I'm not sure I can imagine graphic design history without it.  

natalia ilyin link
6/3/2012 08:45:42 pm

You have just made my day, week, month and year.
Thank you for these kind words.

Laine Nooney
6/4/2012 10:33:22 am

You're welcome--these words are well deserved! It was a gift to teach your book and many of my students admittedly that this was the one book they WEREN'T going to sell back.


Comments are closed.

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    March 2020
    February 2020
    August 2019
    September 2017
    November 2016
    March 2016
    May 2015
    September 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    April 2014
    November 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012

    Categories

    All
    Academia
    Adjunct
    Advertising
    Advice
    Archives
    Broderbund
    Computers
    Conferences
    Different Games
    Diversity
    Ello
    Ergonomics
    Exercises
    Facebook
    Feminism
    Gaming
    Graphic Design
    History
    Illustration
    Inclusivity
    Lunenfeld
    Mass Effect
    Materialism
    Media Archaeology
    Mindfulness
    Objects
    Presentation
    SCMS
    Shot
    Sierra
    Sierra On Line
    Sierra On-Line
    Social Media
    Software
    Stony Brook University
    Syllabus
    Teaching
    Tennis For Two
    Video Games
    Visual Culture
    Visual Culture Association
    Weirdoarchive
    Whgsc
    Writing

ping me: laine.nooney@gmail.com | tweet me: @sierra_offline
© 2020 Laine Nooney.
  • home
  • Research
  • CV
  • Projects
    • Sierra On-Line Memories
    • Mistakes Were Made
    • Softalk Open Discussion Project
    • Academic Coach Taylor
    • JVC Meme Issue
    • T42 Documentary
    • Different Games Conference
    • Freelance Graphic Design
  • Teaching
  • Blog
  • About
  • Prospective Ph.D.